Iyfjky

Question

A player tried to use the spell reduce on his PC while in the mouth of the Tarrasque, then go deeper into its airway and to try to collapse its lung by enlarging himself inside of it. I imagine there's no real rule for this but I felt silly just denying it, because it seemed like a cool idea that you could only probably do with a creature as large as the Tarrasque.

Can you crawl into a gargantuan creatureÃ¢Â€Â™s mouth or into its airway via reduce/enlarge and attack its brain or internal organs?

Related on Aiming at specific body parts
â€“Â NautArch
1 hour ago — 1 hour ago

score 7 · Answer 1 · 2018-11-08 16:02:34Z

You could...but you probably shouldn't. And it may not really matter anyway.

There are a couple of things to consider when determining the possibility of this tactic. The first is whether or not you can get inside the oral cavity of a Tarrasque. This thing is huge, so using Reduce in order to do so seems functionally possible.

The problem is that there really isn't any sort of mechanics for going inside creatures. The bigger issue is likely in entering the Tarrasque in the first place - especially if you go in through the mouth.

The Tarrasque has both a Bite and Swallow attack. If you're inside it's mouth, it's very likely going to use that against you. THe other is the secondary part of the Swallow attack that concerns me more about going inside this dreaded monstrosity:

While swallowed, the creature is blinded and restrained, it has total cover against attacks and other effects outside the tarrasque, and it takes 56 (16d6) acid damage at the start of each of the tarrasque's turns.

Being inside, or at least in the stomach, seems like a particularly dangerous place.

Called Shots

In addition, and more importantly, 5e doesn't have a called shot mechanic. Attacks are much more generalized. What you may consider is reducing the AC, but even that doesn't happen to the Swallowed creature, so I'm not sure there's a precedent for that and would suggest keeping the AC the same.

Getting up there

You should also consider how they're getting into that mouth. This thing is 50' tall, they're going to need to fly up there somehow.

Rule of Cool

However, this is a pretty cool idea. As a DM, you need to balance cool ideas against powerful creatures - and the Tarrasque is one of the most powerful. If you're saying this is a viable tactic, allow called shots, etc. - then you're significantly reducing it's CR as well.

The problem is that once inside the mouth, they are still a candidate for the Tarrasque's Bite and Swallow attacks. I'd also have to heavily consider that if they're already in the mouth/throat of the Tarrasque, the Swallow is likely just going to happen. They don't need to bite them first to get them in their mouth.

It's likely not the best idea functionally even if it sounds cool at first pass.

You might want to include in this answer "how long the tarrasque can flail around while suffocating from the collapsed lung problem" using the suffocation rules and the Tarrasque's high constitution. I might present an answer with that ... — 57 mins ago
@KorvinStarmast Definitely put your answer up. Mine is basically saying that you can't attack the lung. I'm also not sure we know enough about Tarrasque anatomy to determine if a collapsed lung is possible or how it would impact the creature itself. — 54 mins ago

J.E 2,707827 · Answer 2 · 2018-11-08 13:10:57Z

There's not much point.

Let's be frank Ã¢Â€Â“ rules as written there is nothing in 5e about climbing into heads. But setting that aside, let's imagine that you reduce your size enough to climb into a tarrasque's ear or nostril. Well, that's pretty dangerous, now it can attack you even more efficiently. But let's set that aside as well.

Let's say you get into it's ear. Well ears are in no way connected to brain, so not much advantage gained there. You can attempt to hack at it, but that is still the same attack as you could have been doing before you got reduced, only now you substract 1d4 (or more) as per the Reduce effect. So not very effective.

The same story goes for other orifices. Your DM might be kind enough to give you some advantage for attacking some soft tissues if you get to those, but by that time he might also count you as effectively swallowed. The trouble with anything vital is that it's usually inside the creature and to get to it, you would need to slice it open ...which is what you were trying to do in the fist place.

Bonus.

This is going to be completeley in the DM fiat territory, but the rules for reduce state that any item you drop while reduced returns to its original size immediately. So consider bringing a stack of cartoonishly large spears, swords or pikes when getting into that ear and then dropping them carelessly.

as usual Ã¢Â€Â“ if the downvoter could name their reason, it would be appreciated — 2 hours ago
"rules as written there is nothing in 5e about climbing into heads" Ã¢Â€Â” except of the Intellect Devourer, I suppose? (I'm not the downvoter) — 1 hour ago
@enkryptor that's a great point! I would still argue it doesn't apply as it is a very specific ability and there are no gargantuan humanoids. — 1 hour ago

score 2 · Answer 3 · 2018-11-08 16:38:42Z

Rules support for a Rule of Cool attempt

You are in the territory of a GM ruling, and since called shots and attacks on specific body parts aren't covered in the rules, this will probably break down into a three step process (at least) if your innovative PC wants to make this work. It won't be easy, but why not let them try?

Ability Check: Nature or Arcana

The player needs to do the research to find out the weak points of a Tarrasque, and if it in fact has lungs. Let's say say that they pass that ability check, and they find out that Tarrasque does indeed have lungs. (DM ruling; nothing says yes or no in the monster description). So let's roll with this, or you just stop here if the ruling is "no lungs."

Ability Check, Opposed Athletics

Now the PC wants to get into the throat, and then expand into Huge size (see below) without getting swallowed by the Tarrasque.
- A non-trivial technical limitation here is that a Tarrasque can swallow a Large creature, so your PC needs to be able to turn into a Huge Creature, like a T Rex or a Stone Giant. This may call for True Polymorph, rather than Enlarge or Reduce; or, perhaps Polymorph into a Huge creature and be able to "reduce" (per the spell) to become Large to get in, and the dispel / stop being reduced to turn Huge. Unless your PC is already Large, getting from Large to Huge will take some work. Wild Shape? Shapechange? True Polymorph? Note that the PC can't stack enlarge spells to make this work. (See Combining Magical Effects). Assign this research project to your PC: most PC's enjoy a challenge. Research Topic: How to get Huge inside a Tarrasque's Throat?
  
  Once inside the Tarrasque's head/throat, the difficulty is in getting to the "just right" spot in order to expand and try to collapse some lungs since the Tarrasque has this particular ability:
Swallow. The tarrasque makes one bite attack against a Large or smaller creature it is grappling. If the attack hits, the target takes the bite's damage, the target is swallowed, and the grapple ends. While swallowed, the creature is blinded and restrained, it has total cover against attacks and other effects outside the tarrasque, and it takes 56 (16d6) acid damage at the start of each of the tarrasque's turns.

Since the character isn't yet grappled by the bite, per the bite attack description, the issue of being swallowed is in doubt. As DM, this is a fine time to call for an opposed Athletics check (see rules on Contests) with the character's Athletics ability versus the Tarrasque's(Strength Check). The Tarrasque's +10 modifier ups the challenge here. There is a chance to succeed, or a chance to fail. Feel the tension building!

Consider whether or not Advantage or Disadvantage applies here. The DM can always rule that circumstantial advantage, or disadvantage, applies. (Basic Rules, p. 4)

Granted, you as DM could alternatively simply assign a high DC (25-30, maybe higher) for this very difficult task without creating an opposed check. (DMG, DC's; PHB; DC's).

If the PC manages to pull this off, they ought to be able to remain stuck in the Tarrasque since the thing trapped inside is larger than a Large creature, and it won't be barfed up by doing damage to it internally per the "barf 'em up" feature of the Tarrasque:

If the tarrasque takes 60 damage or more on a single turn from a creature inside it, the tarrasque must succeed on a DC 20 Constitution saving throw at the end of that turn or regurgitate all swallowed creatures, which fall prone in a space within 10 feet of the tarrasque. If the tarrasque dies, a swallowed creature is no longer restrained by it and can escape from the corpse by using 30 feet of movement, exiting prone.

OK, the PC has collapsed the lungs, now what? The PC is likely restrained, and may wish to remain so for a while. Why?

It will probably take a while for the Tarrasque to die.

Suffocating

A creature can hold its breath for a number of minutes
equal to 1 + its Constitution modifier (minimum of 30 seconds). When
a creature runs out of breath, it can survive for a number of rounds
equal to its Constitution modifier (minimum 1 round). At the start of
its next turn, it drops to 0 hit points and is dying, and it canÃ¢Â€Â™t
regain hit points or be stabilized until it can breathe again. Basic Rules, p. 65)

The Tarrasque has a Constitution of 30. That's a modifier of +10. It can hold its breath for 11 minutes, and then when it is out of breath, it will choke to death in 10 rounds. (Another minute). You then need to decide ... does the PC also have to deal with a similar problem, stuck there in the Tarrasque's throat? Is oxygen starvation on the table for our brave adventurer? (There are some magic items and spells, and some class abilities, that might mitigate this ....)

If this whole thing succeeds, the PC can wear his, or her, "I Made the Tarrasque Gag!" t-shirt with pride.

This isn't a case of an "I Win" button; this approach looks like a mini-adventure within the larger "fight the Tarrasque" adventure.

score 7 · Answer 4 · 2018-11-08 16:02:34Z

You could...but you probably shouldn't. And it may not really matter anyway.

There are a couple of things to consider when determining the possibility of this tactic. The first is whether or not you can get inside the oral cavity of a Tarrasque. This thing is huge, so using Reduce in order to do so seems functionally possible.

The problem is that there really isn't any sort of mechanics for going inside creatures. The bigger issue is likely in entering the Tarrasque in the first place - especially if you go in through the mouth.

The Tarrasque has both a Bite and Swallow attack. If you're inside it's mouth, it's very likely going to use that against you. THe other is the secondary part of the Swallow attack that concerns me more about going inside this dreaded monstrosity:

While swallowed, the creature is blinded and restrained, it has total cover against attacks and other effects outside the tarrasque, and it takes 56 (16d6) acid damage at the start of each of the tarrasque's turns.

Being inside, or at least in the stomach, seems like a particularly dangerous place.

Called Shots

In addition, and more importantly, 5e doesn't have a called shot mechanic. Attacks are much more generalized. What you may consider is reducing the AC, but even that doesn't happen to the Swallowed creature, so I'm not sure there's a precedent for that and would suggest keeping the AC the same.

Getting up there

You should also consider how they're getting into that mouth. This thing is 50' tall, they're going to need to fly up there somehow.

Rule of Cool

However, this is a pretty cool idea. As a DM, you need to balance cool ideas against powerful creatures - and the Tarrasque is one of the most powerful. If you're saying this is a viable tactic, allow called shots, etc. - then you're significantly reducing it's CR as well.

The problem is that once inside the mouth, they are still a candidate for the Tarrasque's Bite and Swallow attacks. I'd also have to heavily consider that if they're already in the mouth/throat of the Tarrasque, the Swallow is likely just going to happen. They don't need to bite them first to get them in their mouth.

It's likely not the best idea functionally even if it sounds cool at first pass.

You might want to include in this answer "how long the tarrasque can flail around while suffocating from the collapsed lung problem" using the suffocation rules and the Tarrasque's high constitution. I might present an answer with that ... — 57 mins ago
@KorvinStarmast Definitely put your answer up. Mine is basically saying that you can't attack the lung. I'm also not sure we know enough about Tarrasque anatomy to determine if a collapsed lung is possible or how it would impact the creature itself. — 54 mins ago

J.E 2,707827 · Answer 5 · 2018-11-08 13:10:57Z

There's not much point.

Let's be frank Ã¢Â€Â“ rules as written there is nothing in 5e about climbing into heads. But setting that aside, let's imagine that you reduce your size enough to climb into a tarrasque's ear or nostril. Well, that's pretty dangerous, now it can attack you even more efficiently. But let's set that aside as well.

Let's say you get into it's ear. Well ears are in no way connected to brain, so not much advantage gained there. You can attempt to hack at it, but that is still the same attack as you could have been doing before you got reduced, only now you substract 1d4 (or more) as per the Reduce effect. So not very effective.

The same story goes for other orifices. Your DM might be kind enough to give you some advantage for attacking some soft tissues if you get to those, but by that time he might also count you as effectively swallowed. The trouble with anything vital is that it's usually inside the creature and to get to it, you would need to slice it open ...which is what you were trying to do in the fist place.

Bonus.

This is going to be completeley in the DM fiat territory, but the rules for reduce state that any item you drop while reduced returns to its original size immediately. So consider bringing a stack of cartoonishly large spears, swords or pikes when getting into that ear and then dropping them carelessly.

as usual Ã¢Â€Â“ if the downvoter could name their reason, it would be appreciated — 2 hours ago
"rules as written there is nothing in 5e about climbing into heads" Ã¢Â€Â” except of the Intellect Devourer, I suppose? (I'm not the downvoter) — 1 hour ago
@enkryptor that's a great point! I would still argue it doesn't apply as it is a very specific ability and there are no gargantuan humanoids. — 1 hour ago

score 2 · Answer 6 · 2018-11-08 16:38:42Z

Rules support for a Rule of Cool attempt

You are in the territory of a GM ruling, and since called shots and attacks on specific body parts aren't covered in the rules, this will probably break down into a three step process (at least) if your innovative PC wants to make this work. It won't be easy, but why not let them try?

Ability Check: Nature or Arcana

The player needs to do the research to find out the weak points of a Tarrasque, and if it in fact has lungs. Let's say say that they pass that ability check, and they find out that Tarrasque does indeed have lungs. (DM ruling; nothing says yes or no in the monster description). So let's roll with this, or you just stop here if the ruling is "no lungs."

Ability Check, Opposed Athletics

Now the PC wants to get into the throat, and then expand into Huge size (see below) without getting swallowed by the Tarrasque.
- A non-trivial technical limitation here is that a Tarrasque can swallow a Large creature, so your PC needs to be able to turn into a Huge Creature, like a T Rex or a Stone Giant. This may call for True Polymorph, rather than Enlarge or Reduce; or, perhaps Polymorph into a Huge creature and be able to "reduce" (per the spell) to become Large to get in, and the dispel / stop being reduced to turn Huge. Unless your PC is already Large, getting from Large to Huge will take some work. Wild Shape? Shapechange? True Polymorph? Note that the PC can't stack enlarge spells to make this work. (See Combining Magical Effects). Assign this research project to your PC: most PC's enjoy a challenge. Research Topic: How to get Huge inside a Tarrasque's Throat?
  
  Once inside the Tarrasque's head/throat, the difficulty is in getting to the "just right" spot in order to expand and try to collapse some lungs since the Tarrasque has this particular ability:
Swallow. The tarrasque makes one bite attack against a Large or smaller creature it is grappling. If the attack hits, the target takes the bite's damage, the target is swallowed, and the grapple ends. While swallowed, the creature is blinded and restrained, it has total cover against attacks and other effects outside the tarrasque, and it takes 56 (16d6) acid damage at the start of each of the tarrasque's turns.

Since the character isn't yet grappled by the bite, per the bite attack description, the issue of being swallowed is in doubt. As DM, this is a fine time to call for an opposed Athletics check (see rules on Contests) with the character's Athletics ability versus the Tarrasque's(Strength Check). The Tarrasque's +10 modifier ups the challenge here. There is a chance to succeed, or a chance to fail. Feel the tension building!

Consider whether or not Advantage or Disadvantage applies here. The DM can always rule that circumstantial advantage, or disadvantage, applies. (Basic Rules, p. 4)

Granted, you as DM could alternatively simply assign a high DC (25-30, maybe higher) for this very difficult task without creating an opposed check. (DMG, DC's; PHB; DC's).

If the PC manages to pull this off, they ought to be able to remain stuck in the Tarrasque since the thing trapped inside is larger than a Large creature, and it won't be barfed up by doing damage to it internally per the "barf 'em up" feature of the Tarrasque:

If the tarrasque takes 60 damage or more on a single turn from a creature inside it, the tarrasque must succeed on a DC 20 Constitution saving throw at the end of that turn or regurgitate all swallowed creatures, which fall prone in a space within 10 feet of the tarrasque. If the tarrasque dies, a swallowed creature is no longer restrained by it and can escape from the corpse by using 30 feet of movement, exiting prone.

OK, the PC has collapsed the lungs, now what? The PC is likely restrained, and may wish to remain so for a while. Why?

It will probably take a while for the Tarrasque to die.

Suffocating

A creature can hold its breath for a number of minutes
equal to 1 + its Constitution modifier (minimum of 30 seconds). When
a creature runs out of breath, it can survive for a number of rounds
equal to its Constitution modifier (minimum 1 round). At the start of
its next turn, it drops to 0 hit points and is dying, and it canÃ¢Â€Â™t
regain hit points or be stabilized until it can breathe again. Basic Rules, p. 65)

The Tarrasque has a Constitution of 30. That's a modifier of +10. It can hold its breath for 11 minutes, and then when it is out of breath, it will choke to death in 10 rounds. (Another minute). You then need to decide ... does the PC also have to deal with a similar problem, stuck there in the Tarrasque's throat? Is oxygen starvation on the table for our brave adventurer? (There are some magic items and spells, and some class abilities, that might mitigate this ....)

If this whole thing succeeds, the PC can wear his, or her, "I Made the Tarrasque Gag!" t-shirt with pride.

This isn't a case of an "I Win" button; this approach looks like a mini-adventure within the larger "fight the Tarrasque" adventure.

Category

Random preview

Can you reduce yourself, crawl into the Tarrasque's airway, and try to collapse its lung by enlarging inside of it?

3 Answers 3

You could...but you probably shouldn't. And it may not really matter anyway.

Called Shots

Getting up there

Rule of Cool

There's not much point.

Bonus.

Rules support for a Rule of Cool attempt

It will probably take a while for the Tarrasque to die.

Your Answer

Sign up or log in

Post as a guest

Post as a guest

3 Answers 3

3 Answers 3

You could...but you probably shouldn't. And it may not really matter anyway.

Called Shots

Getting up there

Rule of Cool

You could...but you probably shouldn't. And it may not really matter anyway.

Called Shots

Getting up there

Rule of Cool

You could...but you probably shouldn't. And it may not really matter anyway.

Called Shots

Getting up there

Rule of Cool

You could...but you probably shouldn't. And it may not really matter anyway.

Called Shots

Getting up there

Rule of Cool

There's not much point.

Bonus.

There's not much point.

Bonus.

There's not much point.

Bonus.

There's not much point.

Bonus.

Rules support for a Rule of Cool attempt

It will probably take a while for the Tarrasque to die.

Rules support for a Rule of Cool attempt

It will probably take a while for the Tarrasque to die.

Rules support for a Rule of Cool attempt

It will probably take a while for the Tarrasque to die.

Rules support for a Rule of Cool attempt

It will probably take a while for the Tarrasque to die.

Sign up or log in

Post as a guest

Post as a guest

Sign up or log in

Post as a guest

Sign up or log in

Post as a guest

Sign up or log in

Post as a guest

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Long meetings (6-7 hours a day): Being â€œbabysatâ€ by supervisor

Is the Concept of Multiple Fantasy Races Scientifically Flawed? [closed]

Confectionery

3 Answers
3

3 Answers
3

3 Answers
3

Long meetings (6-7 hours a day): Being â€œbabysatâ€ by supervisor