Mixing
Is it safe to cut or shave the roots of a Norway Maple tree?
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
4
down vote
favorite
My deck was built 30 years age around a Norway Maple. Now it has grown to the point that the roots are lifting parts of the deck. It is safe to cut or shave the roots that are lifting the deck?
trees roots maple
edited Aug 21 at 23:08
Sue
4,64031953
asked Aug 21 at 17:00
Michelle Day-McKenna
211
add a comment |Â
up vote
4
down vote
favorite
My deck was built 30 years age around a Norway Maple. Now it has grown to the point that the roots are lifting parts of the deck. It is safe to cut or shave the roots that are lifting the deck?
trees roots maple
edited Aug 21 at 23:08
Sue
4,64031953
asked Aug 21 at 17:00
Michelle Day-McKenna
211
Welcome! Would you please post some pictures, especially where the roots are coming through the deck? This is an excellent first question! You'll see I changed the title because we prefer our titles to be in the form of a question. I also added a bit of detail to be more specific to what you asked. Our site is different from some other kinds, so I invite you to look around our help center. If you have questions about our features or how to do anything, leave us a comment and someone will help you! Have fun!I
– Sue
Aug 21 at 23:28
What you're making me think about is a video on inter-cropping from Mark Shepard (author of Restoration Agriculture: Real-world Permaculture for Farmers) on permaculture design. Essentially what you want to do to send deep roots is till the area year after year to tell the roots grow deep or get cut off.
– black thumb
Aug 22 at 2:04
add a comment |Â
up vote
4
down vote
favorite
up vote
4
down vote
favorite
My deck was built 30 years age around a Norway Maple. Now it has grown to the point that the roots are lifting parts of the deck. It is safe to cut or shave the roots that are lifting the deck?
trees roots maple
edited Aug 21 at 23:08
Sue
4,64031953
asked Aug 21 at 17:00
Michelle Day-McKenna
211
My deck was built 30 years age around a Norway Maple. Now it has grown to the point that the roots are lifting parts of the deck. It is safe to cut or shave the roots that are lifting the deck?
trees roots maple
edited Aug 21 at 23:08
Sue
4,64031953
asked Aug 21 at 17:00
Michelle Day-McKenna
211
edited Aug 21 at 23:08
Sue
4,64031953
edited Aug 21 at 23:08
Sue
4,64031953
edited Aug 21 at 23:08
Sue
4,64031953
4,64031953
asked Aug 21 at 17:00
Michelle Day-McKenna
211
asked Aug 21 at 17:00
Michelle Day-McKenna
211
asked Aug 21 at 17:00
Michelle Day-McKenna
211
211
Welcome! Would you please post some pictures, especially where the roots are coming through the deck? This is an excellent first question! You'll see I changed the title because we prefer our titles to be in the form of a question. I also added a bit of detail to be more specific to what you asked. Our site is different from some other kinds, so I invite you to look around our help center. If you have questions about our features or how to do anything, leave us a comment and someone will help you! Have fun!I
– Sue
Aug 21 at 23:28
What you're making me think about is a video on inter-cropping from Mark Shepard (author of Restoration Agriculture: Real-world Permaculture for Farmers) on permaculture design. Essentially what you want to do to send deep roots is till the area year after year to tell the roots grow deep or get cut off.
– black thumb
Aug 22 at 2:04
add a comment |Â
Welcome! Would you please post some pictures, especially where the roots are coming through the deck? This is an excellent first question! You'll see I changed the title because we prefer our titles to be in the form of a question. I also added a bit of detail to be more specific to what you asked. Our site is different from some other kinds, so I invite you to look around our help center. If you have questions about our features or how to do anything, leave us a comment and someone will help you! Have fun!I
– Sue
Aug 21 at 23:28
What you're making me think about is a video on inter-cropping from Mark Shepard (author of Restoration Agriculture: Real-world Permaculture for Farmers) on permaculture design. Essentially what you want to do to send deep roots is till the area year after year to tell the roots grow deep or get cut off.
– black thumb
Aug 22 at 2:04
Welcome! Would you please post some pictures, especially where the roots are coming through the deck? This is an excellent first question! You'll see I changed the title because we prefer our titles to be in the form of a question. I also added a bit of detail to be more specific to what you asked. Our site is different from some other kinds, so I invite you to look around our help center. If you have questions about our features or how to do anything, leave us a comment and someone will help you! Have fun!I
– Sue
Aug 21 at 23:28
Welcome! Would you please post some pictures, especially where the roots are coming through the deck? This is an excellent first question! You'll see I changed the title because we prefer our titles to be in the form of a question. I also added a bit of detail to be more specific to what you asked. Our site is different from some other kinds, so I invite you to look around our help center. If you have questions about our features or how to do anything, leave us a comment and someone will help you! Have fun!I
– Sue
Aug 21 at 23:28
What you're making me think about is a video on inter-cropping from Mark Shepard (author of Restoration Agriculture: Real-world Permaculture for Farmers) on permaculture design. Essentially what you want to do to send deep roots is till the area year after year to tell the roots grow deep or get cut off.
– black thumb
Aug 22 at 2:04
What you're making me think about is a video on inter-cropping from Mark Shepard (author of Restoration Agriculture: Real-world Permaculture for Farmers) on permaculture design. Essentially what you want to do to send deep roots is till the area year after year to tell the roots grow deep or get cut off.
– black thumb
Aug 22 at 2:04
add a comment |Â
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
up vote
2
down vote
Norway maple is one of the trees that is fairly shallow rooted, and frequently has roots above soil level. This happens regardless of the oxygen content in the soil, though it will produce surface roots much more quickly if the soil it grows in is very compacted.
It is not wise to shave or remove any larger roots - this may compromise the health of the tree. However, given it's uprooting your deck, you might want to consider removing that tree and planting a new tree. Otherwise, call an arborist, who should be able to give you good advice in respect of being able to remove any roots at all. Some information in this link here https://www.bowerandbranch.com/dealing-with-trees-with-surface-roots/#.W3xwrqDTUn4
answered Aug 21 at 20:10
Bamboo
104k252138
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
In general, no because trees that have roots above ground need to have roots above ground. Usually, this is because the tree is having trouble finding the oxygen it needs from the soil.
That being said, Maple is one of a few species of trees that has a tendency to grow roots above ground despite living in oxygen enriched soil. So it might be possible for you to cut or shave the roots depending on the oxygen quality of your soil.
There are various methods for determining if your soil is oxygen rich or poor but the only method I have knowledge of is using a sensor. You can purchase them at your garden store or online. If you do end up going this route I would consult an arborist in your neighborhood first. Also, remember that if you reduce root volume you need to reduce canopy volume as well.
However, even if you soil is oxygen rich there are other problems that could crop up by cutting or weakening surface roots. Tree stability for instance. There are methods and steps that can be taken such as digging up the root and burying it further but to be honest it may just end up being more cost effective for you to build a new deck or update the existing one to cope with the tree's growing patterns.
edited Aug 21 at 20:11
Bamboo
104k252138
answered Aug 21 at 19:23
Rob
45612
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
Whew, shaving off the tops of those roots is just wrong! They are the trunks of the underground system of roots. A good carpenter could easily remake the deck to accommodate a growing tree. Simply jacking up the deck and extending posts or adding blocking will raise the deck easily. I'd like to see how the deck connects to the home. Is it level with the floor of your home or are you stepping up from the deck to get into the home?
If all you need to do is the area right around the base of your tree, the floor taken away can be made into raised benches and tables for potted flowers, food and beverages...that tree deserves to stay right where it is, it is part of your family by now, no shaving. To make it easier, make a square instead of a circle around your tree.
Spread crushed gravel around the base of the tree if there is too much mud. Even potted plants can be staged around the base. Please send a picture or two.
answered Aug 21 at 21:20
stormy
36.7k21968
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
You do not say where you are, but in many places, like North America, Norway maples are invasive. If so, do everyone around you a favor and cut the tree down completely. You could replace it with a sugar maple, possibly.
answered Aug 21 at 23:32
Olin Lathrop
1092
add a comment |Â
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
2
down vote
Norway maple is one of the trees that is fairly shallow rooted, and frequently has roots above soil level. This happens regardless of the oxygen content in the soil, though it will produce surface roots much more quickly if the soil it grows in is very compacted.
It is not wise to shave or remove any larger roots - this may compromise the health of the tree. However, given it's uprooting your deck, you might want to consider removing that tree and planting a new tree. Otherwise, call an arborist, who should be able to give you good advice in respect of being able to remove any roots at all. Some information in this link here https://www.bowerandbranch.com/dealing-with-trees-with-surface-roots/#.W3xwrqDTUn4
answered Aug 21 at 20:10
Bamboo
104k252138
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
Norway maple is one of the trees that is fairly shallow rooted, and frequently has roots above soil level. This happens regardless of the oxygen content in the soil, though it will produce surface roots much more quickly if the soil it grows in is very compacted.
It is not wise to shave or remove any larger roots - this may compromise the health of the tree. However, given it's uprooting your deck, you might want to consider removing that tree and planting a new tree. Otherwise, call an arborist, who should be able to give you good advice in respect of being able to remove any roots at all. Some information in this link here https://www.bowerandbranch.com/dealing-with-trees-with-surface-roots/#.W3xwrqDTUn4
answered Aug 21 at 20:10
Bamboo
104k252138
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
up vote
2
down vote
Norway maple is one of the trees that is fairly shallow rooted, and frequently has roots above soil level. This happens regardless of the oxygen content in the soil, though it will produce surface roots much more quickly if the soil it grows in is very compacted.
It is not wise to shave or remove any larger roots - this may compromise the health of the tree. However, given it's uprooting your deck, you might want to consider removing that tree and planting a new tree. Otherwise, call an arborist, who should be able to give you good advice in respect of being able to remove any roots at all. Some information in this link here https://www.bowerandbranch.com/dealing-with-trees-with-surface-roots/#.W3xwrqDTUn4
answered Aug 21 at 20:10
Bamboo
104k252138
Norway maple is one of the trees that is fairly shallow rooted, and frequently has roots above soil level. This happens regardless of the oxygen content in the soil, though it will produce surface roots much more quickly if the soil it grows in is very compacted.
It is not wise to shave or remove any larger roots - this may compromise the health of the tree. However, given it's uprooting your deck, you might want to consider removing that tree and planting a new tree. Otherwise, call an arborist, who should be able to give you good advice in respect of being able to remove any roots at all. Some information in this link here https://www.bowerandbranch.com/dealing-with-trees-with-surface-roots/#.W3xwrqDTUn4
answered Aug 21 at 20:10
Bamboo
104k252138
answered Aug 21 at 20:10
Bamboo
104k252138
answered Aug 21 at 20:10
Bamboo
104k252138
answered Aug 21 at 20:10
Bamboo
104k252138
104k252138
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
In general, no because trees that have roots above ground need to have roots above ground. Usually, this is because the tree is having trouble finding the oxygen it needs from the soil.
That being said, Maple is one of a few species of trees that has a tendency to grow roots above ground despite living in oxygen enriched soil. So it might be possible for you to cut or shave the roots depending on the oxygen quality of your soil.
There are various methods for determining if your soil is oxygen rich or poor but the only method I have knowledge of is using a sensor. You can purchase them at your garden store or online. If you do end up going this route I would consult an arborist in your neighborhood first. Also, remember that if you reduce root volume you need to reduce canopy volume as well.
However, even if you soil is oxygen rich there are other problems that could crop up by cutting or weakening surface roots. Tree stability for instance. There are methods and steps that can be taken such as digging up the root and burying it further but to be honest it may just end up being more cost effective for you to build a new deck or update the existing one to cope with the tree's growing patterns.
edited Aug 21 at 20:11
Bamboo
104k252138
answered Aug 21 at 19:23
Rob
45612
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
In general, no because trees that have roots above ground need to have roots above ground. Usually, this is because the tree is having trouble finding the oxygen it needs from the soil.
That being said, Maple is one of a few species of trees that has a tendency to grow roots above ground despite living in oxygen enriched soil. So it might be possible for you to cut or shave the roots depending on the oxygen quality of your soil.
There are various methods for determining if your soil is oxygen rich or poor but the only method I have knowledge of is using a sensor. You can purchase them at your garden store or online. If you do end up going this route I would consult an arborist in your neighborhood first. Also, remember that if you reduce root volume you need to reduce canopy volume as well.
However, even if you soil is oxygen rich there are other problems that could crop up by cutting or weakening surface roots. Tree stability for instance. There are methods and steps that can be taken such as digging up the root and burying it further but to be honest it may just end up being more cost effective for you to build a new deck or update the existing one to cope with the tree's growing patterns.
edited Aug 21 at 20:11
Bamboo
104k252138
answered Aug 21 at 19:23
Rob
45612
add a comment |Â
up vote
2
down vote
up vote
2
down vote
In general, no because trees that have roots above ground need to have roots above ground. Usually, this is because the tree is having trouble finding the oxygen it needs from the soil.
That being said, Maple is one of a few species of trees that has a tendency to grow roots above ground despite living in oxygen enriched soil. So it might be possible for you to cut or shave the roots depending on the oxygen quality of your soil.
There are various methods for determining if your soil is oxygen rich or poor but the only method I have knowledge of is using a sensor. You can purchase them at your garden store or online. If you do end up going this route I would consult an arborist in your neighborhood first. Also, remember that if you reduce root volume you need to reduce canopy volume as well.
However, even if you soil is oxygen rich there are other problems that could crop up by cutting or weakening surface roots. Tree stability for instance. There are methods and steps that can be taken such as digging up the root and burying it further but to be honest it may just end up being more cost effective for you to build a new deck or update the existing one to cope with the tree's growing patterns.
edited Aug 21 at 20:11
Bamboo
104k252138
answered Aug 21 at 19:23
Rob
45612
In general, no because trees that have roots above ground need to have roots above ground. Usually, this is because the tree is having trouble finding the oxygen it needs from the soil.
That being said, Maple is one of a few species of trees that has a tendency to grow roots above ground despite living in oxygen enriched soil. So it might be possible for you to cut or shave the roots depending on the oxygen quality of your soil.
There are various methods for determining if your soil is oxygen rich or poor but the only method I have knowledge of is using a sensor. You can purchase them at your garden store or online. If you do end up going this route I would consult an arborist in your neighborhood first. Also, remember that if you reduce root volume you need to reduce canopy volume as well.
However, even if you soil is oxygen rich there are other problems that could crop up by cutting or weakening surface roots. Tree stability for instance. There are methods and steps that can be taken such as digging up the root and burying it further but to be honest it may just end up being more cost effective for you to build a new deck or update the existing one to cope with the tree's growing patterns.
edited Aug 21 at 20:11
Bamboo
104k252138
answered Aug 21 at 19:23
Rob
45612
edited Aug 21 at 20:11
Bamboo
104k252138
edited Aug 21 at 20:11
Bamboo
104k252138
edited Aug 21 at 20:11
Bamboo
104k252138
104k252138
answered Aug 21 at 19:23
Rob
45612
answered Aug 21 at 19:23
Rob
45612
answered Aug 21 at 19:23
Rob
45612
45612
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
Whew, shaving off the tops of those roots is just wrong! They are the trunks of the underground system of roots. A good carpenter could easily remake the deck to accommodate a growing tree. Simply jacking up the deck and extending posts or adding blocking will raise the deck easily. I'd like to see how the deck connects to the home. Is it level with the floor of your home or are you stepping up from the deck to get into the home?
If all you need to do is the area right around the base of your tree, the floor taken away can be made into raised benches and tables for potted flowers, food and beverages...that tree deserves to stay right where it is, it is part of your family by now, no shaving. To make it easier, make a square instead of a circle around your tree.
Spread crushed gravel around the base of the tree if there is too much mud. Even potted plants can be staged around the base. Please send a picture or two.
answered Aug 21 at 21:20
stormy
36.7k21968
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
Whew, shaving off the tops of those roots is just wrong! They are the trunks of the underground system of roots. A good carpenter could easily remake the deck to accommodate a growing tree. Simply jacking up the deck and extending posts or adding blocking will raise the deck easily. I'd like to see how the deck connects to the home. Is it level with the floor of your home or are you stepping up from the deck to get into the home?
If all you need to do is the area right around the base of your tree, the floor taken away can be made into raised benches and tables for potted flowers, food and beverages...that tree deserves to stay right where it is, it is part of your family by now, no shaving. To make it easier, make a square instead of a circle around your tree.
Spread crushed gravel around the base of the tree if there is too much mud. Even potted plants can be staged around the base. Please send a picture or two.
answered Aug 21 at 21:20
stormy
36.7k21968
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
Whew, shaving off the tops of those roots is just wrong! They are the trunks of the underground system of roots. A good carpenter could easily remake the deck to accommodate a growing tree. Simply jacking up the deck and extending posts or adding blocking will raise the deck easily. I'd like to see how the deck connects to the home. Is it level with the floor of your home or are you stepping up from the deck to get into the home?
If all you need to do is the area right around the base of your tree, the floor taken away can be made into raised benches and tables for potted flowers, food and beverages...that tree deserves to stay right where it is, it is part of your family by now, no shaving. To make it easier, make a square instead of a circle around your tree.
Spread crushed gravel around the base of the tree if there is too much mud. Even potted plants can be staged around the base. Please send a picture or two.
answered Aug 21 at 21:20
stormy
36.7k21968
Whew, shaving off the tops of those roots is just wrong! They are the trunks of the underground system of roots. A good carpenter could easily remake the deck to accommodate a growing tree. Simply jacking up the deck and extending posts or adding blocking will raise the deck easily. I'd like to see how the deck connects to the home. Is it level with the floor of your home or are you stepping up from the deck to get into the home?
If all you need to do is the area right around the base of your tree, the floor taken away can be made into raised benches and tables for potted flowers, food and beverages...that tree deserves to stay right where it is, it is part of your family by now, no shaving. To make it easier, make a square instead of a circle around your tree.
Spread crushed gravel around the base of the tree if there is too much mud. Even potted plants can be staged around the base. Please send a picture or two.
answered Aug 21 at 21:20
stormy
36.7k21968
edited Aug 21 at 21:38
answered Aug 21 at 21:20
stormy
36.7k21968
answered Aug 21 at 21:20
stormy
36.7k21968
answered Aug 21 at 21:20
stormy
36.7k21968
36.7k21968
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
You do not say where you are, but in many places, like North America, Norway maples are invasive. If so, do everyone around you a favor and cut the tree down completely. You could replace it with a sugar maple, possibly.
answered Aug 21 at 23:32
Olin Lathrop
1092
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
You do not say where you are, but in many places, like North America, Norway maples are invasive. If so, do everyone around you a favor and cut the tree down completely. You could replace it with a sugar maple, possibly.
answered Aug 21 at 23:32
Olin Lathrop
1092
add a comment |Â
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
You do not say where you are, but in many places, like North America, Norway maples are invasive. If so, do everyone around you a favor and cut the tree down completely. You could replace it with a sugar maple, possibly.
answered Aug 21 at 23:32
Olin Lathrop
1092
You do not say where you are, but in many places, like North America, Norway maples are invasive. If so, do everyone around you a favor and cut the tree down completely. You could replace it with a sugar maple, possibly.
answered Aug 21 at 23:32
Olin Lathrop
1092
answered Aug 21 at 23:32
Olin Lathrop
1092
answered Aug 21 at 23:32
Olin Lathrop
1092
answered Aug 21 at 23:32
Olin Lathrop
1092
1092
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fgardening.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f41610%2fis-it-safe-to-cut-or-shave-the-roots-of-a-norway-maple-tree%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Welcome! Would you please post some pictures, especially where the roots are coming through the deck? This is an excellent first question! You'll see I changed the title because we prefer our titles to be in the form of a question. I also added a bit of detail to be more specific to what you asked. Our site is different from some other kinds, so I invite you to look around our help center. If you have questions about our features or how to do anything, leave us a comment and someone will help you! Have fun!I
– Sue
Aug 21 at 23:28
What you're making me think about is a video on inter-cropping from Mark Shepard (author of Restoration Agriculture: Real-world Permaculture for Farmers) on permaculture design. Essentially what you want to do to send deep roots is till the area year after year to tell the roots grow deep or get cut off.
– black thumb
Aug 22 at 2:04