Mixing
Is Thor indestructible?
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;
up vote
11
down vote
favorite
In Thor: Ragnarok, especially, Thor has a monumental battle in the arena with the Hulk receiving not physical damage (ok he got knocked out but didn't even get a black eye) yet in his fight with Hela he loses an eye and gets stabbed in the back a few times. Does he receive this damage because he is related to Hela therefore they can damage each other, or because he is in Asgard?
marvel marvel-cinematic-universe thor-marvel thor-ragnarok
edited 5 hours ago
phantom42
109k42481697
asked Sep 2 at 15:16
Seamusthedog
6701316
 |Â
show 1 more comment
up vote
11
down vote
favorite
In Thor: Ragnarok, especially, Thor has a monumental battle in the arena with the Hulk receiving not physical damage (ok he got knocked out but didn't even get a black eye) yet in his fight with Hela he loses an eye and gets stabbed in the back a few times. Does he receive this damage because he is related to Hela therefore they can damage each other, or because he is in Asgard?
marvel marvel-cinematic-universe thor-marvel thor-ragnarok
edited 5 hours ago
phantom42
109k42481697
asked Sep 2 at 15:16
Seamusthedog
6701316
3
In the latest film he nearly died
– Valorum
Sep 2 at 15:23
1
Nearly but not quite
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 15:25
1
It's worth noting that any injuries received from the hulk would be in the form of blunt force trauma which is often much less obvious than getting cut/stabbed. Especially if asguardians don't visibly bruise (we have no reason to think they do, i don't think)
– Ummdustry
Sep 2 at 16:04
4
The title and body of this question don't match.
– Möoz
Sep 3 at 1:14
1
"Tell me... do you bruise?"
– Taladris
Sep 3 at 4:14
 |Â
show 1 more comment
up vote
11
down vote
favorite
up vote
11
down vote
favorite
In Thor: Ragnarok, especially, Thor has a monumental battle in the arena with the Hulk receiving not physical damage (ok he got knocked out but didn't even get a black eye) yet in his fight with Hela he loses an eye and gets stabbed in the back a few times. Does he receive this damage because he is related to Hela therefore they can damage each other, or because he is in Asgard?
marvel marvel-cinematic-universe thor-marvel thor-ragnarok
edited 5 hours ago
phantom42
109k42481697
asked Sep 2 at 15:16
Seamusthedog
6701316
In Thor: Ragnarok, especially, Thor has a monumental battle in the arena with the Hulk receiving not physical damage (ok he got knocked out but didn't even get a black eye) yet in his fight with Hela he loses an eye and gets stabbed in the back a few times. Does he receive this damage because he is related to Hela therefore they can damage each other, or because he is in Asgard?
marvel marvel-cinematic-universe thor-marvel thor-ragnarok
edited 5 hours ago
phantom42
109k42481697
asked Sep 2 at 15:16
Seamusthedog
6701316
edited 5 hours ago
phantom42
109k42481697
edited 5 hours ago
phantom42
109k42481697
edited 5 hours ago
phantom42
109k42481697
109k42481697
asked Sep 2 at 15:16
Seamusthedog
6701316
asked Sep 2 at 15:16
Seamusthedog
6701316
asked Sep 2 at 15:16
Seamusthedog
6701316
6701316
3
In the latest film he nearly died
– Valorum
Sep 2 at 15:23
1
Nearly but not quite
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 15:25
1
It's worth noting that any injuries received from the hulk would be in the form of blunt force trauma which is often much less obvious than getting cut/stabbed. Especially if asguardians don't visibly bruise (we have no reason to think they do, i don't think)
– Ummdustry
Sep 2 at 16:04
4
The title and body of this question don't match.
– Möoz
Sep 3 at 1:14
1
"Tell me... do you bruise?"
– Taladris
Sep 3 at 4:14
 |Â
show 1 more comment
3
In the latest film he nearly died
– Valorum
Sep 2 at 15:23
1
Nearly but not quite
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 15:25
1
It's worth noting that any injuries received from the hulk would be in the form of blunt force trauma which is often much less obvious than getting cut/stabbed. Especially if asguardians don't visibly bruise (we have no reason to think they do, i don't think)
– Ummdustry
Sep 2 at 16:04
4
The title and body of this question don't match.
– Möoz
Sep 3 at 1:14
1
"Tell me... do you bruise?"
– Taladris
Sep 3 at 4:14
3
3
In the latest film he nearly died
– Valorum
Sep 2 at 15:23
In the latest film he nearly died
– Valorum
Sep 2 at 15:23
1
1
Nearly but not quite
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 15:25
Nearly but not quite
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 15:25
1
1
It's worth noting that any injuries received from the hulk would be in the form of blunt force trauma which is often much less obvious than getting cut/stabbed. Especially if asguardians don't visibly bruise (we have no reason to think they do, i don't think)
– Ummdustry
Sep 2 at 16:04
It's worth noting that any injuries received from the hulk would be in the form of blunt force trauma which is often much less obvious than getting cut/stabbed. Especially if asguardians don't visibly bruise (we have no reason to think they do, i don't think)
– Ummdustry
Sep 2 at 16:04
4
4
The title and body of this question don't match.
– Möoz
Sep 3 at 1:14
The title and body of this question don't match.
– Möoz
Sep 3 at 1:14
1
1
"Tell me... do you bruise?"
– Taladris
Sep 3 at 4:14
"Tell me... do you bruise?"
– Taladris
Sep 3 at 4:14
 |Â
show 1 more comment
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
up vote
20
down vote
Thor acknowledges his own mortality in Avengers: Infinity War:
Thor: You know, I'm 1,500 years old. I've killed twice as many enemies as that, and every one of them would have rather killed me, but none succeeded. I'm only alive because Fate wants me alive. Thanos is just the latest in a long line of bastards, and he'll be the latest to feel my vengeance. Fate wills it so.
In the same movie, Thor also:
took the full heat of the dying star when making Stormbreaker and was knocked out for several moments, with the implication that this almost killed him.
Therefore, it stands to reason that he is not indestructible.
Regarding the specific movie, Thor: Ragnarok, it is actually said that Hela is stronger than all other living Asgardians at the moment:
Loki: She's stronger than both of us. She's stronger than you. You don't stand a chance.
Therefore, since Hela quite easily tore out Thor's eye, then she could also probably fatally wound him and indeed that seems to be her intent in the movie.
edited Sep 2 at 22:30
Edlothiad
54k20284294
answered Sep 2 at 15:30
Loki
4,13832147
3
I get that but immortal and indestructible are different. Getting your head pounded on by the Hulk without a scratch when soon after you loose an eye seems weird.
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 15:39
2
Does it matter? Hela took his eye out, Hulk KO'd him and fatally wounded but he still manages to jump up 2 minutes later with hardly a mark (although Banner jumps out the ship onto the Bifrost bridge, lands on his face and gets up 2 minutes later)
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 16:20
6
@Seamusthedog, it's pretty obvious that the movies don't follow physics as we understand them. See: Capt America's solid shield "absorbs blows", but he can still hit with it....
– Paul Draper
Sep 3 at 1:29
2
@Seamusthedog I'm glad we were able to help! If you think you are covered by my answer, please consider accepting it :)
– Loki
Sep 3 at 12:45
2
@Seamusthedog - Not a problem!... that is what this site exists for!
– Odin1806
Sep 3 at 16:18
 |Â
show 6 more comments
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
1 Answer
1
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
20
down vote
Thor acknowledges his own mortality in Avengers: Infinity War:
Thor: You know, I'm 1,500 years old. I've killed twice as many enemies as that, and every one of them would have rather killed me, but none succeeded. I'm only alive because Fate wants me alive. Thanos is just the latest in a long line of bastards, and he'll be the latest to feel my vengeance. Fate wills it so.
In the same movie, Thor also:
took the full heat of the dying star when making Stormbreaker and was knocked out for several moments, with the implication that this almost killed him.
Therefore, it stands to reason that he is not indestructible.
Regarding the specific movie, Thor: Ragnarok, it is actually said that Hela is stronger than all other living Asgardians at the moment:
Loki: She's stronger than both of us. She's stronger than you. You don't stand a chance.
Therefore, since Hela quite easily tore out Thor's eye, then she could also probably fatally wound him and indeed that seems to be her intent in the movie.
edited Sep 2 at 22:30
Edlothiad
54k20284294
answered Sep 2 at 15:30
Loki
4,13832147
3
I get that but immortal and indestructible are different. Getting your head pounded on by the Hulk without a scratch when soon after you loose an eye seems weird.
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 15:39
2
Does it matter? Hela took his eye out, Hulk KO'd him and fatally wounded but he still manages to jump up 2 minutes later with hardly a mark (although Banner jumps out the ship onto the Bifrost bridge, lands on his face and gets up 2 minutes later)
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 16:20
6
@Seamusthedog, it's pretty obvious that the movies don't follow physics as we understand them. See: Capt America's solid shield "absorbs blows", but he can still hit with it....
– Paul Draper
Sep 3 at 1:29
2
@Seamusthedog I'm glad we were able to help! If you think you are covered by my answer, please consider accepting it :)
– Loki
Sep 3 at 12:45
2
@Seamusthedog - Not a problem!... that is what this site exists for!
– Odin1806
Sep 3 at 16:18
 |Â
show 6 more comments
up vote
20
down vote
Thor acknowledges his own mortality in Avengers: Infinity War:
Thor: You know, I'm 1,500 years old. I've killed twice as many enemies as that, and every one of them would have rather killed me, but none succeeded. I'm only alive because Fate wants me alive. Thanos is just the latest in a long line of bastards, and he'll be the latest to feel my vengeance. Fate wills it so.
In the same movie, Thor also:
took the full heat of the dying star when making Stormbreaker and was knocked out for several moments, with the implication that this almost killed him.
Therefore, it stands to reason that he is not indestructible.
Regarding the specific movie, Thor: Ragnarok, it is actually said that Hela is stronger than all other living Asgardians at the moment:
Loki: She's stronger than both of us. She's stronger than you. You don't stand a chance.
Therefore, since Hela quite easily tore out Thor's eye, then she could also probably fatally wound him and indeed that seems to be her intent in the movie.
edited Sep 2 at 22:30
Edlothiad
54k20284294
answered Sep 2 at 15:30
Loki
4,13832147
3
I get that but immortal and indestructible are different. Getting your head pounded on by the Hulk without a scratch when soon after you loose an eye seems weird.
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 15:39
2
Does it matter? Hela took his eye out, Hulk KO'd him and fatally wounded but he still manages to jump up 2 minutes later with hardly a mark (although Banner jumps out the ship onto the Bifrost bridge, lands on his face and gets up 2 minutes later)
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 16:20
6
@Seamusthedog, it's pretty obvious that the movies don't follow physics as we understand them. See: Capt America's solid shield "absorbs blows", but he can still hit with it....
– Paul Draper
Sep 3 at 1:29
2
@Seamusthedog I'm glad we were able to help! If you think you are covered by my answer, please consider accepting it :)
– Loki
Sep 3 at 12:45
2
@Seamusthedog - Not a problem!... that is what this site exists for!
– Odin1806
Sep 3 at 16:18
 |Â
show 6 more comments
up vote
20
down vote
up vote
20
down vote
Thor acknowledges his own mortality in Avengers: Infinity War:
Thor: You know, I'm 1,500 years old. I've killed twice as many enemies as that, and every one of them would have rather killed me, but none succeeded. I'm only alive because Fate wants me alive. Thanos is just the latest in a long line of bastards, and he'll be the latest to feel my vengeance. Fate wills it so.
In the same movie, Thor also:
took the full heat of the dying star when making Stormbreaker and was knocked out for several moments, with the implication that this almost killed him.
Therefore, it stands to reason that he is not indestructible.
Regarding the specific movie, Thor: Ragnarok, it is actually said that Hela is stronger than all other living Asgardians at the moment:
Loki: She's stronger than both of us. She's stronger than you. You don't stand a chance.
Therefore, since Hela quite easily tore out Thor's eye, then she could also probably fatally wound him and indeed that seems to be her intent in the movie.
edited Sep 2 at 22:30
Edlothiad
54k20284294
answered Sep 2 at 15:30
Loki
4,13832147
Thor acknowledges his own mortality in Avengers: Infinity War:
Thor: You know, I'm 1,500 years old. I've killed twice as many enemies as that, and every one of them would have rather killed me, but none succeeded. I'm only alive because Fate wants me alive. Thanos is just the latest in a long line of bastards, and he'll be the latest to feel my vengeance. Fate wills it so.
In the same movie, Thor also:
took the full heat of the dying star when making Stormbreaker and was knocked out for several moments, with the implication that this almost killed him.
Therefore, it stands to reason that he is not indestructible.
Regarding the specific movie, Thor: Ragnarok, it is actually said that Hela is stronger than all other living Asgardians at the moment:
Loki: She's stronger than both of us. She's stronger than you. You don't stand a chance.
Therefore, since Hela quite easily tore out Thor's eye, then she could also probably fatally wound him and indeed that seems to be her intent in the movie.
edited Sep 2 at 22:30
Edlothiad
54k20284294
answered Sep 2 at 15:30
Loki
4,13832147
edited Sep 2 at 22:30
Edlothiad
54k20284294
edited Sep 2 at 22:30
Edlothiad
54k20284294
edited Sep 2 at 22:30
Edlothiad
54k20284294
54k20284294
answered Sep 2 at 15:30
Loki
4,13832147
answered Sep 2 at 15:30
Loki
4,13832147
answered Sep 2 at 15:30
Loki
4,13832147
4,13832147
3
I get that but immortal and indestructible are different. Getting your head pounded on by the Hulk without a scratch when soon after you loose an eye seems weird.
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 15:39
2
Does it matter? Hela took his eye out, Hulk KO'd him and fatally wounded but he still manages to jump up 2 minutes later with hardly a mark (although Banner jumps out the ship onto the Bifrost bridge, lands on his face and gets up 2 minutes later)
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 16:20
6
@Seamusthedog, it's pretty obvious that the movies don't follow physics as we understand them. See: Capt America's solid shield "absorbs blows", but he can still hit with it....
– Paul Draper
Sep 3 at 1:29
2
@Seamusthedog I'm glad we were able to help! If you think you are covered by my answer, please consider accepting it :)
– Loki
Sep 3 at 12:45
2
@Seamusthedog - Not a problem!... that is what this site exists for!
– Odin1806
Sep 3 at 16:18
 |Â
show 6 more comments
3
I get that but immortal and indestructible are different. Getting your head pounded on by the Hulk without a scratch when soon after you loose an eye seems weird.
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 15:39
2
Does it matter? Hela took his eye out, Hulk KO'd him and fatally wounded but he still manages to jump up 2 minutes later with hardly a mark (although Banner jumps out the ship onto the Bifrost bridge, lands on his face and gets up 2 minutes later)
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 16:20
6
@Seamusthedog, it's pretty obvious that the movies don't follow physics as we understand them. See: Capt America's solid shield "absorbs blows", but he can still hit with it....
– Paul Draper
Sep 3 at 1:29
2
@Seamusthedog I'm glad we were able to help! If you think you are covered by my answer, please consider accepting it :)
– Loki
Sep 3 at 12:45
2
@Seamusthedog - Not a problem!... that is what this site exists for!
– Odin1806
Sep 3 at 16:18
3
3
I get that but immortal and indestructible are different. Getting your head pounded on by the Hulk without a scratch when soon after you loose an eye seems weird.
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 15:39
I get that but immortal and indestructible are different. Getting your head pounded on by the Hulk without a scratch when soon after you loose an eye seems weird.
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 15:39
2
2
Does it matter? Hela took his eye out, Hulk KO'd him and fatally wounded but he still manages to jump up 2 minutes later with hardly a mark (although Banner jumps out the ship onto the Bifrost bridge, lands on his face and gets up 2 minutes later)
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 16:20
Does it matter? Hela took his eye out, Hulk KO'd him and fatally wounded but he still manages to jump up 2 minutes later with hardly a mark (although Banner jumps out the ship onto the Bifrost bridge, lands on his face and gets up 2 minutes later)
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 16:20
6
6
@Seamusthedog, it's pretty obvious that the movies don't follow physics as we understand them. See: Capt America's solid shield "absorbs blows", but he can still hit with it....
– Paul Draper
Sep 3 at 1:29
@Seamusthedog, it's pretty obvious that the movies don't follow physics as we understand them. See: Capt America's solid shield "absorbs blows", but he can still hit with it....
– Paul Draper
Sep 3 at 1:29
2
2
@Seamusthedog I'm glad we were able to help! If you think you are covered by my answer, please consider accepting it :)
– Loki
Sep 3 at 12:45
@Seamusthedog I'm glad we were able to help! If you think you are covered by my answer, please consider accepting it :)
– Loki
Sep 3 at 12:45
2
2
@Seamusthedog - Not a problem!... that is what this site exists for!
– Odin1806
Sep 3 at 16:18
@Seamusthedog - Not a problem!... that is what this site exists for!
– Odin1806
Sep 3 at 16:18
 |Â
show 6 more comments
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f194082%2fis-thor-indestructible%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
3
In the latest film he nearly died
– Valorum
Sep 2 at 15:23
1
Nearly but not quite
– Seamusthedog
Sep 2 at 15:25
1
It's worth noting that any injuries received from the hulk would be in the form of blunt force trauma which is often much less obvious than getting cut/stabbed. Especially if asguardians don't visibly bruise (we have no reason to think they do, i don't think)
– Ummdustry
Sep 2 at 16:04
4
The title and body of this question don't match.
– Möoz
Sep 3 at 1:14
1
"Tell me... do you bruise?"
– Taladris
Sep 3 at 4:14