Would Shocking Grasp prevent the target from casting Absorb Elements?
Clash Royale CLAN TAG#URR8PPP
up vote
7
down vote
favorite
If a creature uses Shocking Grasp on another creature that uses its reaction to cast Absorb Elements, will Shocking Grasp, which stops a creature from using reactions, prevent the casting of Absorb Elements since Shocking Grasp should happen first before Absorb Elements does?
dnd-5e spells cantrips
add a comment |Â
up vote
7
down vote
favorite
If a creature uses Shocking Grasp on another creature that uses its reaction to cast Absorb Elements, will Shocking Grasp, which stops a creature from using reactions, prevent the casting of Absorb Elements since Shocking Grasp should happen first before Absorb Elements does?
dnd-5e spells cantrips
2
Related: Can the Shield spell be used against Shocking Grasp?
â Sdjz
2 hours ago
add a comment |Â
up vote
7
down vote
favorite
up vote
7
down vote
favorite
If a creature uses Shocking Grasp on another creature that uses its reaction to cast Absorb Elements, will Shocking Grasp, which stops a creature from using reactions, prevent the casting of Absorb Elements since Shocking Grasp should happen first before Absorb Elements does?
dnd-5e spells cantrips
If a creature uses Shocking Grasp on another creature that uses its reaction to cast Absorb Elements, will Shocking Grasp, which stops a creature from using reactions, prevent the casting of Absorb Elements since Shocking Grasp should happen first before Absorb Elements does?
dnd-5e spells cantrips
dnd-5e spells cantrips
edited 10 mins ago
V2Blast
17.5k247112
17.5k247112
asked 2 hours ago
Cyanic
3367
3367
2
Related: Can the Shield spell be used against Shocking Grasp?
â Sdjz
2 hours ago
add a comment |Â
2
Related: Can the Shield spell be used against Shocking Grasp?
â Sdjz
2 hours ago
2
2
Related: Can the Shield spell be used against Shocking Grasp?
â Sdjz
2 hours ago
Related: Can the Shield spell be used against Shocking Grasp?
â Sdjz
2 hours ago
add a comment |Â
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
up vote
8
down vote
Correct, you cannot cast absorb elements in response to shocking grasp
Reactions happen after their triggers unless specified otherwise. The trigger for absorb elements is taking damage...
Reaction which you take when you take acid, cold, fire, lightning, or thunder damage
...but when you take damage from shocking grasp, you can't cast reactions anymore:
ÃÂ On a hit, the target takes 1d8 lightning damage, and it can't take reactions until the start of its next turn
This means that you never have the opportunity to cast absorb elements, as you correctly deduced.
This is different from shield because shield triggers when you are hit while absorb elements triggers when you take damage. You aren't reaction-blocked until after the hit, and shield can intercede in that hit.
@CTWind yes, but you can't actually use absorb elements until you take the damage (so regardless, you are reaction blocked)
â David Coffron
1 hour ago
Note that the answer you linked specifically calls out Absorb Elements as an interrupting reaction, allowing you to cast it before Shocking Grasps effect happens.
â GreySage
1 hour ago
@GreySage it interrupts the damage taking (which is the trigger), not the hit (which causes the reaction-block)
â David Coffron
1 hour ago
add a comment |Â
up vote
-2
down vote
Specific (spell block text) > General (core rule text)
âÂÂWhen you play the Game of Exception, you either treat spell effects equally or you dieâÂÂ
This is specific to this scenario, normal reaction accounts for a single effect or action and continues the same turn. But this reaction is triggered by the lightning damage, thus using his current reaction and negating next turns reaction.
- Creature A. casts Shocking Grasp
- Creature B. (primary effect)is hit and takes xd8 lightning damage
- Creature B. casts Absorb Elements as a reaction, triggered by lightning damage, (primary effect) reducing said lightning damage by half.
- Creature A. (secondary effect) activates and target canâÂÂt use reactions til end of his next turn.
- Creature B. (secondary effect) activates and an extra d6 damage effect with next melee Attack on next turn.
add a comment |Â
up vote
-3
down vote
No, you can cast Absorb Elements when (about to be) hit by Shocking Grasp
According to this answer (backed by Crawford), Absorb Elements applies to the triggering attack.
Q: Does Absorb Elements give you resistance to damage from the triggering attack?
A: Yes.
You cannot take damage, and then halve that damage (the damage is already taken and done with).
Therefore, Absorb Elements must be cast before taking damage from the attack, which is before the effect of Shocking Grasp prevents the reaction.
Normally reactions that interrupt an attack (between roll and the effects happening) specifically call out that they are interrupting (see Shield). In Absorb Elements case it doesn't, but the only way for the spell to work as intended is for it to work the same way. This problem probably stems from the fact that Absorb Elements was published in a campaign module not a regular rulebook. Such things tend to have a lower level of Quality Assurance applied to them.
1
This doesn't necessarily mean that the reaction is taken before the damage. There are other effects which retroactively influence outcomes (like the shield spell or a bard's Cutting Words)
â David Coffron
2 hours ago
You should quote Crawford directly instead of relying on another questionâÂÂs answer. I might change it in the future, after all, if a future errata or Crawford statement changes the answer.
â SevenSidedDieâ¦
2 hours ago
@DavidCoffron Likewise, you can cast shield when hit by Shocking Grasp (see related)
â GreySage
2 hours ago
@SevenSidedDie Yes, I just added that in.
â GreySage
2 hours ago
3
ItâÂÂs also worth considering that the other question, and CrawfordâÂÂs tweet, are clarifying the normal effect of Absorb Elements. It may be a stretch to say Crawford was also ruling on unusual interactions that werenâÂÂt mentioned at the time.
â SevenSidedDieâ¦
2 hours ago
 |Â
show 2 more comments
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
8
down vote
Correct, you cannot cast absorb elements in response to shocking grasp
Reactions happen after their triggers unless specified otherwise. The trigger for absorb elements is taking damage...
Reaction which you take when you take acid, cold, fire, lightning, or thunder damage
...but when you take damage from shocking grasp, you can't cast reactions anymore:
ÃÂ On a hit, the target takes 1d8 lightning damage, and it can't take reactions until the start of its next turn
This means that you never have the opportunity to cast absorb elements, as you correctly deduced.
This is different from shield because shield triggers when you are hit while absorb elements triggers when you take damage. You aren't reaction-blocked until after the hit, and shield can intercede in that hit.
@CTWind yes, but you can't actually use absorb elements until you take the damage (so regardless, you are reaction blocked)
â David Coffron
1 hour ago
Note that the answer you linked specifically calls out Absorb Elements as an interrupting reaction, allowing you to cast it before Shocking Grasps effect happens.
â GreySage
1 hour ago
@GreySage it interrupts the damage taking (which is the trigger), not the hit (which causes the reaction-block)
â David Coffron
1 hour ago
add a comment |Â
up vote
8
down vote
Correct, you cannot cast absorb elements in response to shocking grasp
Reactions happen after their triggers unless specified otherwise. The trigger for absorb elements is taking damage...
Reaction which you take when you take acid, cold, fire, lightning, or thunder damage
...but when you take damage from shocking grasp, you can't cast reactions anymore:
ÃÂ On a hit, the target takes 1d8 lightning damage, and it can't take reactions until the start of its next turn
This means that you never have the opportunity to cast absorb elements, as you correctly deduced.
This is different from shield because shield triggers when you are hit while absorb elements triggers when you take damage. You aren't reaction-blocked until after the hit, and shield can intercede in that hit.
@CTWind yes, but you can't actually use absorb elements until you take the damage (so regardless, you are reaction blocked)
â David Coffron
1 hour ago
Note that the answer you linked specifically calls out Absorb Elements as an interrupting reaction, allowing you to cast it before Shocking Grasps effect happens.
â GreySage
1 hour ago
@GreySage it interrupts the damage taking (which is the trigger), not the hit (which causes the reaction-block)
â David Coffron
1 hour ago
add a comment |Â
up vote
8
down vote
up vote
8
down vote
Correct, you cannot cast absorb elements in response to shocking grasp
Reactions happen after their triggers unless specified otherwise. The trigger for absorb elements is taking damage...
Reaction which you take when you take acid, cold, fire, lightning, or thunder damage
...but when you take damage from shocking grasp, you can't cast reactions anymore:
ÃÂ On a hit, the target takes 1d8 lightning damage, and it can't take reactions until the start of its next turn
This means that you never have the opportunity to cast absorb elements, as you correctly deduced.
This is different from shield because shield triggers when you are hit while absorb elements triggers when you take damage. You aren't reaction-blocked until after the hit, and shield can intercede in that hit.
Correct, you cannot cast absorb elements in response to shocking grasp
Reactions happen after their triggers unless specified otherwise. The trigger for absorb elements is taking damage...
Reaction which you take when you take acid, cold, fire, lightning, or thunder damage
...but when you take damage from shocking grasp, you can't cast reactions anymore:
ÃÂ On a hit, the target takes 1d8 lightning damage, and it can't take reactions until the start of its next turn
This means that you never have the opportunity to cast absorb elements, as you correctly deduced.
This is different from shield because shield triggers when you are hit while absorb elements triggers when you take damage. You aren't reaction-blocked until after the hit, and shield can intercede in that hit.
edited 1 hour ago
answered 2 hours ago
David Coffron
31k2106214
31k2106214
@CTWind yes, but you can't actually use absorb elements until you take the damage (so regardless, you are reaction blocked)
â David Coffron
1 hour ago
Note that the answer you linked specifically calls out Absorb Elements as an interrupting reaction, allowing you to cast it before Shocking Grasps effect happens.
â GreySage
1 hour ago
@GreySage it interrupts the damage taking (which is the trigger), not the hit (which causes the reaction-block)
â David Coffron
1 hour ago
add a comment |Â
@CTWind yes, but you can't actually use absorb elements until you take the damage (so regardless, you are reaction blocked)
â David Coffron
1 hour ago
Note that the answer you linked specifically calls out Absorb Elements as an interrupting reaction, allowing you to cast it before Shocking Grasps effect happens.
â GreySage
1 hour ago
@GreySage it interrupts the damage taking (which is the trigger), not the hit (which causes the reaction-block)
â David Coffron
1 hour ago
@CTWind yes, but you can't actually use absorb elements until you take the damage (so regardless, you are reaction blocked)
â David Coffron
1 hour ago
@CTWind yes, but you can't actually use absorb elements until you take the damage (so regardless, you are reaction blocked)
â David Coffron
1 hour ago
Note that the answer you linked specifically calls out Absorb Elements as an interrupting reaction, allowing you to cast it before Shocking Grasps effect happens.
â GreySage
1 hour ago
Note that the answer you linked specifically calls out Absorb Elements as an interrupting reaction, allowing you to cast it before Shocking Grasps effect happens.
â GreySage
1 hour ago
@GreySage it interrupts the damage taking (which is the trigger), not the hit (which causes the reaction-block)
â David Coffron
1 hour ago
@GreySage it interrupts the damage taking (which is the trigger), not the hit (which causes the reaction-block)
â David Coffron
1 hour ago
add a comment |Â
up vote
-2
down vote
Specific (spell block text) > General (core rule text)
âÂÂWhen you play the Game of Exception, you either treat spell effects equally or you dieâÂÂ
This is specific to this scenario, normal reaction accounts for a single effect or action and continues the same turn. But this reaction is triggered by the lightning damage, thus using his current reaction and negating next turns reaction.
- Creature A. casts Shocking Grasp
- Creature B. (primary effect)is hit and takes xd8 lightning damage
- Creature B. casts Absorb Elements as a reaction, triggered by lightning damage, (primary effect) reducing said lightning damage by half.
- Creature A. (secondary effect) activates and target canâÂÂt use reactions til end of his next turn.
- Creature B. (secondary effect) activates and an extra d6 damage effect with next melee Attack on next turn.
add a comment |Â
up vote
-2
down vote
Specific (spell block text) > General (core rule text)
âÂÂWhen you play the Game of Exception, you either treat spell effects equally or you dieâÂÂ
This is specific to this scenario, normal reaction accounts for a single effect or action and continues the same turn. But this reaction is triggered by the lightning damage, thus using his current reaction and negating next turns reaction.
- Creature A. casts Shocking Grasp
- Creature B. (primary effect)is hit and takes xd8 lightning damage
- Creature B. casts Absorb Elements as a reaction, triggered by lightning damage, (primary effect) reducing said lightning damage by half.
- Creature A. (secondary effect) activates and target canâÂÂt use reactions til end of his next turn.
- Creature B. (secondary effect) activates and an extra d6 damage effect with next melee Attack on next turn.
add a comment |Â
up vote
-2
down vote
up vote
-2
down vote
Specific (spell block text) > General (core rule text)
âÂÂWhen you play the Game of Exception, you either treat spell effects equally or you dieâÂÂ
This is specific to this scenario, normal reaction accounts for a single effect or action and continues the same turn. But this reaction is triggered by the lightning damage, thus using his current reaction and negating next turns reaction.
- Creature A. casts Shocking Grasp
- Creature B. (primary effect)is hit and takes xd8 lightning damage
- Creature B. casts Absorb Elements as a reaction, triggered by lightning damage, (primary effect) reducing said lightning damage by half.
- Creature A. (secondary effect) activates and target canâÂÂt use reactions til end of his next turn.
- Creature B. (secondary effect) activates and an extra d6 damage effect with next melee Attack on next turn.
Specific (spell block text) > General (core rule text)
âÂÂWhen you play the Game of Exception, you either treat spell effects equally or you dieâÂÂ
This is specific to this scenario, normal reaction accounts for a single effect or action and continues the same turn. But this reaction is triggered by the lightning damage, thus using his current reaction and negating next turns reaction.
- Creature A. casts Shocking Grasp
- Creature B. (primary effect)is hit and takes xd8 lightning damage
- Creature B. casts Absorb Elements as a reaction, triggered by lightning damage, (primary effect) reducing said lightning damage by half.
- Creature A. (secondary effect) activates and target canâÂÂt use reactions til end of his next turn.
- Creature B. (secondary effect) activates and an extra d6 damage effect with next melee Attack on next turn.
answered 39 mins ago
XAQT78
539111
539111
add a comment |Â
add a comment |Â
up vote
-3
down vote
No, you can cast Absorb Elements when (about to be) hit by Shocking Grasp
According to this answer (backed by Crawford), Absorb Elements applies to the triggering attack.
Q: Does Absorb Elements give you resistance to damage from the triggering attack?
A: Yes.
You cannot take damage, and then halve that damage (the damage is already taken and done with).
Therefore, Absorb Elements must be cast before taking damage from the attack, which is before the effect of Shocking Grasp prevents the reaction.
Normally reactions that interrupt an attack (between roll and the effects happening) specifically call out that they are interrupting (see Shield). In Absorb Elements case it doesn't, but the only way for the spell to work as intended is for it to work the same way. This problem probably stems from the fact that Absorb Elements was published in a campaign module not a regular rulebook. Such things tend to have a lower level of Quality Assurance applied to them.
1
This doesn't necessarily mean that the reaction is taken before the damage. There are other effects which retroactively influence outcomes (like the shield spell or a bard's Cutting Words)
â David Coffron
2 hours ago
You should quote Crawford directly instead of relying on another questionâÂÂs answer. I might change it in the future, after all, if a future errata or Crawford statement changes the answer.
â SevenSidedDieâ¦
2 hours ago
@DavidCoffron Likewise, you can cast shield when hit by Shocking Grasp (see related)
â GreySage
2 hours ago
@SevenSidedDie Yes, I just added that in.
â GreySage
2 hours ago
3
ItâÂÂs also worth considering that the other question, and CrawfordâÂÂs tweet, are clarifying the normal effect of Absorb Elements. It may be a stretch to say Crawford was also ruling on unusual interactions that werenâÂÂt mentioned at the time.
â SevenSidedDieâ¦
2 hours ago
 |Â
show 2 more comments
up vote
-3
down vote
No, you can cast Absorb Elements when (about to be) hit by Shocking Grasp
According to this answer (backed by Crawford), Absorb Elements applies to the triggering attack.
Q: Does Absorb Elements give you resistance to damage from the triggering attack?
A: Yes.
You cannot take damage, and then halve that damage (the damage is already taken and done with).
Therefore, Absorb Elements must be cast before taking damage from the attack, which is before the effect of Shocking Grasp prevents the reaction.
Normally reactions that interrupt an attack (between roll and the effects happening) specifically call out that they are interrupting (see Shield). In Absorb Elements case it doesn't, but the only way for the spell to work as intended is for it to work the same way. This problem probably stems from the fact that Absorb Elements was published in a campaign module not a regular rulebook. Such things tend to have a lower level of Quality Assurance applied to them.
1
This doesn't necessarily mean that the reaction is taken before the damage. There are other effects which retroactively influence outcomes (like the shield spell or a bard's Cutting Words)
â David Coffron
2 hours ago
You should quote Crawford directly instead of relying on another questionâÂÂs answer. I might change it in the future, after all, if a future errata or Crawford statement changes the answer.
â SevenSidedDieâ¦
2 hours ago
@DavidCoffron Likewise, you can cast shield when hit by Shocking Grasp (see related)
â GreySage
2 hours ago
@SevenSidedDie Yes, I just added that in.
â GreySage
2 hours ago
3
ItâÂÂs also worth considering that the other question, and CrawfordâÂÂs tweet, are clarifying the normal effect of Absorb Elements. It may be a stretch to say Crawford was also ruling on unusual interactions that werenâÂÂt mentioned at the time.
â SevenSidedDieâ¦
2 hours ago
 |Â
show 2 more comments
up vote
-3
down vote
up vote
-3
down vote
No, you can cast Absorb Elements when (about to be) hit by Shocking Grasp
According to this answer (backed by Crawford), Absorb Elements applies to the triggering attack.
Q: Does Absorb Elements give you resistance to damage from the triggering attack?
A: Yes.
You cannot take damage, and then halve that damage (the damage is already taken and done with).
Therefore, Absorb Elements must be cast before taking damage from the attack, which is before the effect of Shocking Grasp prevents the reaction.
Normally reactions that interrupt an attack (between roll and the effects happening) specifically call out that they are interrupting (see Shield). In Absorb Elements case it doesn't, but the only way for the spell to work as intended is for it to work the same way. This problem probably stems from the fact that Absorb Elements was published in a campaign module not a regular rulebook. Such things tend to have a lower level of Quality Assurance applied to them.
No, you can cast Absorb Elements when (about to be) hit by Shocking Grasp
According to this answer (backed by Crawford), Absorb Elements applies to the triggering attack.
Q: Does Absorb Elements give you resistance to damage from the triggering attack?
A: Yes.
You cannot take damage, and then halve that damage (the damage is already taken and done with).
Therefore, Absorb Elements must be cast before taking damage from the attack, which is before the effect of Shocking Grasp prevents the reaction.
Normally reactions that interrupt an attack (between roll and the effects happening) specifically call out that they are interrupting (see Shield). In Absorb Elements case it doesn't, but the only way for the spell to work as intended is for it to work the same way. This problem probably stems from the fact that Absorb Elements was published in a campaign module not a regular rulebook. Such things tend to have a lower level of Quality Assurance applied to them.
edited 1 hour ago
Rubiksmoose
41.8k5205318
41.8k5205318
answered 2 hours ago
GreySage
12.9k44686
12.9k44686
1
This doesn't necessarily mean that the reaction is taken before the damage. There are other effects which retroactively influence outcomes (like the shield spell or a bard's Cutting Words)
â David Coffron
2 hours ago
You should quote Crawford directly instead of relying on another questionâÂÂs answer. I might change it in the future, after all, if a future errata or Crawford statement changes the answer.
â SevenSidedDieâ¦
2 hours ago
@DavidCoffron Likewise, you can cast shield when hit by Shocking Grasp (see related)
â GreySage
2 hours ago
@SevenSidedDie Yes, I just added that in.
â GreySage
2 hours ago
3
ItâÂÂs also worth considering that the other question, and CrawfordâÂÂs tweet, are clarifying the normal effect of Absorb Elements. It may be a stretch to say Crawford was also ruling on unusual interactions that werenâÂÂt mentioned at the time.
â SevenSidedDieâ¦
2 hours ago
 |Â
show 2 more comments
1
This doesn't necessarily mean that the reaction is taken before the damage. There are other effects which retroactively influence outcomes (like the shield spell or a bard's Cutting Words)
â David Coffron
2 hours ago
You should quote Crawford directly instead of relying on another questionâÂÂs answer. I might change it in the future, after all, if a future errata or Crawford statement changes the answer.
â SevenSidedDieâ¦
2 hours ago
@DavidCoffron Likewise, you can cast shield when hit by Shocking Grasp (see related)
â GreySage
2 hours ago
@SevenSidedDie Yes, I just added that in.
â GreySage
2 hours ago
3
ItâÂÂs also worth considering that the other question, and CrawfordâÂÂs tweet, are clarifying the normal effect of Absorb Elements. It may be a stretch to say Crawford was also ruling on unusual interactions that werenâÂÂt mentioned at the time.
â SevenSidedDieâ¦
2 hours ago
1
1
This doesn't necessarily mean that the reaction is taken before the damage. There are other effects which retroactively influence outcomes (like the shield spell or a bard's Cutting Words)
â David Coffron
2 hours ago
This doesn't necessarily mean that the reaction is taken before the damage. There are other effects which retroactively influence outcomes (like the shield spell or a bard's Cutting Words)
â David Coffron
2 hours ago
You should quote Crawford directly instead of relying on another questionâÂÂs answer. I might change it in the future, after all, if a future errata or Crawford statement changes the answer.
â SevenSidedDieâ¦
2 hours ago
You should quote Crawford directly instead of relying on another questionâÂÂs answer. I might change it in the future, after all, if a future errata or Crawford statement changes the answer.
â SevenSidedDieâ¦
2 hours ago
@DavidCoffron Likewise, you can cast shield when hit by Shocking Grasp (see related)
â GreySage
2 hours ago
@DavidCoffron Likewise, you can cast shield when hit by Shocking Grasp (see related)
â GreySage
2 hours ago
@SevenSidedDie Yes, I just added that in.
â GreySage
2 hours ago
@SevenSidedDie Yes, I just added that in.
â GreySage
2 hours ago
3
3
ItâÂÂs also worth considering that the other question, and CrawfordâÂÂs tweet, are clarifying the normal effect of Absorb Elements. It may be a stretch to say Crawford was also ruling on unusual interactions that werenâÂÂt mentioned at the time.
â SevenSidedDieâ¦
2 hours ago
ItâÂÂs also worth considering that the other question, and CrawfordâÂÂs tweet, are clarifying the normal effect of Absorb Elements. It may be a stretch to say Crawford was also ruling on unusual interactions that werenâÂÂt mentioned at the time.
â SevenSidedDieâ¦
2 hours ago
 |Â
show 2 more comments
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2frpg.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f135190%2fwould-shocking-grasp-prevent-the-target-from-casting-absorb-elements%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
2
Related: Can the Shield spell be used against Shocking Grasp?
â Sdjz
2 hours ago